In his open letter to Google John M. Simpson, Privacy Project Director of Consumer Watchdog, is asking them to implement the EU’s “Right to be Forgotten” for US users on a voluntary basis too. His main argument why Google.com should do so, is that removals of links are not automated. Google has to strike a balance between the interests involved and seems to be doing so quite successfully, as Simpson states:
“I was heartened to see – based on Google’s own numbers – that you appear able to strike this balance in Europe and it does not appear to be an undue burden on your resources.”
The numbers seem pretty promising. So far, Google has received approx. 150’000 removal requests since the CJEU’s decision in May 2014 and has removed approx. 48% of the links in question, keeping the rest online. Thus, Simpson argues in his letter that striking a balance between the respective interests has proven to be easy enough for Google so why not provide the same “service” for US users.
Interesting enough there seems to be a slow movement going on in the US towards more privacy on the Internet. Let’s see if Europe and the US can find common grounds in the near future. Here’s the letter
for further reading.
Data Protection, Google, privacy, right to be forgotten